Mar 22 2012 | Posted by wun

Clash of the crayfish: why the Americans are winning

American signal crayfish

Aggressive American signal crayfish are threatening Yorkshire’s native white-clawed crayfish populations because they have better resistance to parasites and are less fussy about what they eat.

The native crayfish suffers from two parasites; plague, which is carried by the American invader, as well as porcelain disease which makes the native crayfish sluggish and suppresses their appetite before eventually killing them a few years later.

Yorkshire is one of the last strongholds of the white-clawed crayfish, which is being driven out of Britain's waterways by its hardier American cousin, introduced to Britain in the 1970s for fish farming. The advance of the signal crayfish over its native rival has implications for the biodiversity of Britain's rivers as the diversity of prey is reduced and the invaders' appetite for fish eggs causes a decline in the fish population.

Although the white-clawed crayfish is listed as an endangered species in Britain, the reasons for its decline and the American species' success have not been well understood. Now, researchers from the University of Leeds' Faculty of Biological Sciences have been trying to work out why the signal crayfish has been gaining the upper hand, and how this information might be used in conservation projects.

Their study, published in the online journal PLoS One, compares how quickly the two different species deal with food. The American signal crayfish ate up to 83 per cent more food per day than did their native cousins. The research also showed that white-clawed crayfish are much more choosy about what they eat, preferring particular types of prey, while the signals eat equal amounts of all prey. The white-clawed crayfish are also affected by a common parasite, porcelain disease, which affects their ability to catch prey, leading affected crayfish to eat 30% less. The American signal crayfish, on the other hand, seem unaffected by the parasite.

Dr Alison Dunn, of the Faculty of Biological Sciences, at the University of Leeds, who led the study, explains:

“The signals eat much more compared with the native crayfish. But the situation is exacerbated by a parasite which essentially changes the native's behaviour – the white-clawed crayfish can't eat or handle as much food as the signal, because the parasite weakens its muscles.”

“The huge appetites of the signal crayfish can have a massive effect on the whole ecosystem,” adds Dr Dunn. “In particular it affects biodiversity because there is a reduction in the numbers of prey. In some Yorkshire rivers, for example, the fish population has declined because signal crayfish are eating large numbers of fish eggs.”

Dr Dunn believes studying the effects of parasites on host species can offer vital clues about species conservation.

“Parasites are a fascinating and vital part of any ecosystem and you have to consider their effects when looking at biological invasions,” she says. “We hope our findings will help us make predictions about how this invader might spread and help with management strategies.”

Humans too can play a part in protecting the white-clawed crayfish by understanding how invading species spread. The signal crayfish is able to move overland of its own accord, but may also be inadvertently moved around in, for example, damp fishing gear.

“We need to be much more careful about how we move animals and plants around from habitat to habitat, and raise public awareness about these issues,” says Dr Dunn.

The research was funded by the Natural Environment Research Council, in partnership with the Environment Agency. It is one of many projects run by the Yorkshire Dales Environment Network , set up to care for and manage the Yorkshire Dales.
Image credit: Dunn Laboratory, University of Leeds

For more information please contact:

Beck Lockwood, Campus PR tel 0121 451 1321; mob 0778 3802318; email

University of Leeds Press Office, tel 0113 343 4031.

Notes for editors:

  1. This study was published online on 16 February 2012 in the journal {i:PLoS One} in a paper entitled Predatory Functional Response and Prey Choice Identify Predation Differences between Native/Invasive and Parasitised/Unparasitised Crayfish, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0032229
  2. Work showing the impact of the invader on fish populations was published in 2009. Peay et al 2009 . Knowledge and management of aquatic ecosystems 394-395
  3. Dr Alison Dunn can be heard talking about her research in a podcast 'Invasive signal crayfish, shags, night-shining clouds' on the Natural Environment Research Council's research news website Planet Earth Online. Listen here:
  4. The Faculty of Biological Sciences at the University of Leeds is one of the largest in the UK, with over 150 academic staff and over 400 postdoctoral fellows and postgraduate students. The Faculty is ranked 4th in the UK (Nature Journal, 457 (2009) doi :10.1038/457013a) based on results of the 2008 Research Assessment Exercise (RAE). The RAE feedback noted that “virtually all outputs were assessed as being recognized internationally, with many (60%) being internationally excellent or world-leading” in quality. The Faculty's research grant portfolio totals some £60M and funders include charities, research councils, the European Union and industry.
  5. The 2008 Research Assessment Exercise showed the University of Leeds to be the UK's eighth biggest research powerhouse. The University is one of the largest higher education institutions in the UK and a member of the Russell Group of research-intensive universities. The University's vision is to secure a place among the world's top 50 by 2015. The University of Leeds is acclaimed for the quality of its teaching and research. One of the largest universities in the UK, Leeds is also the most popular among students applying for undergraduate courses. An emphasis on innovative research and investment in high-quality facilities and first-rate infrastructure means that no fewer than 35 departments are rated internationally or nationally 'excellent'.
  6. A crayfish picture is available. Please contact Campus PR if you would like a copy.
  7. The Yorkshire Dales Environment Network ( is a partnership between many of the landowners and organisations involved in the daily life and long term protection of the Yorkshire Dales. The Network's aim is to balance and enhance the work of its members by facilitating information exchange and collaboration, whilst protecting the unique landscape and biodiversity that make the Dales such an iconic and special place.