Loss and damage (L&D) is generally defined as the residual cost to of climate change to societies, after mitigation and adaptation. Some aspects of LD can be given an economic value (e.g. damage to infrastructure), but other aspects are difficult or impossible to value economically (e.g. identity and place), and are termed non-economic or non-market loss and damage (NMLD). Some NMLDs may be the most highly valued by individuals and communities, but their incommensurability means that they are in danger of being ignored or undervalued when considering LD, especially in the context of prioritising adaptation.
We explore possible frameworks to NMLD “valuation” that are consistent with recent thinking about limits to adaptation, tolerable and intolerable losses. Drawing on case studies of climate change impacts from across the developed and developing world, we re-interrogate previous literature to define a typology of NMLD through the lens of what people value, and the potential for loss. We use case studies that represent different livelihoods and climatic stressors, for instance from the Western Australian Wheat Belt, New Orleans, Niue Island in the South Pacific, dryland farming systems in Northern Ghana, and indigenous populations in the United States and Australia.
Instead of starting with current and future impacts from climate change and assessing economic and non-economic losses for all possible loss categories, we start with what people in specific places value and how these aspects are affected by climate change. Not every potential loss is valued the same, and some losses might be larger and harder to avoid, than others. “Intolerable” loss might occur when, despite adaptive action, a highly valued private or social norm is threatened. However, what people value might change over time, with new understandings of risk, adaptation options, and likely impacts, and with social and cultural change. Hence, any useful analytical framework for NMLD has to be iterative and reflexive, and it has to have a time dimension.
Some of our main questions for deliberation are:
• What are the domains of L&D under climate change?
• What is a meaningful baseline for determining loss?
• When, where, and for whom are L&D irrevesible?
• What methodologies and approaches exist or need to be amended to best assess harm, in monetary and non-monetary terms?
• What is the basis for estimating and allocating reparation and compensation?
◦Tschakert, P., N. R. Ellis, C. Anderson, A. Kelly, and J. Obeng (2019). One thousand ways to experience loss: A systematic analysis of climate-related intangible harm from around the world. Global Environmental Change 55: 58-72.
◦ Crosweller, M., & Tschakert, P. (2019). Climate change and disasters: The ethics of leadership. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, e624.
◦ Tschakert, P., Ellis, N.R., Anderson, C., Kelly, A. and Obeng, J., 2019. One thousand ways to experience loss: A systematic analysis of climate-related intangible harm from around the world. Global Environmental Change, 55, pp.58-72.
◦ Roy, J., Tschakert, P., Waisman, H. et al., 2018. Sustainable Development, Poverty Eradication and Reducing Inequalities. Chapter 5 in IPCC Special Report 1.5C.
◦ Tschakert, P., Barnett, J., Ellis, N., Lawrence, C., Tuana, N., New, M., Elrick‐Barr, C., Pandit, R. and Pannell, D., 2017. Climate change and loss, as if people mattered: values, places, and experiences. WIREs: Climate Change, 8(5).
Professor Petra Tschakert, UWA
Professor David Pannell, UWA
Professor Carmen Lawrence, UWA
Dr. Ram Pandit, UWA
Dr. Sarah Prout Quicke, UWA
Dr. Marit Kragt, UWA
Dr. Alka Sabharwal, UWA
Karen Paiva Henrique, UWA
Dr. Neville Ellis, Murdoch University
Carmen Elric-Barr, University of the Sunshine Coast
Patrick Pearlmann, Environmental Defender’s Office WA
Professor Jon Barnett, University of Melbourne
Professor Margaret Alston, Monash University
Dr. Naomi Godden, Monash University
Professor Alistair Woodward, University of Auckland
Professor Mark New, University of Cape Town
Associate Professor Gina Ziervogel, University of Cape Town
Irene Kunamwene, University of Cape Town
Dr. Mumuni Abu, University of Ghana
Reuben Tete Larbi, University of Ghana
Dr. Susannah Sallu, University of Leeds
Professor Nancy Tuana, Pennsylvania State University
Dr. Doug Bassette, Ohio State University